An immersive experience of a book

This is a beautiful book - perhaps not an adjective usually found applied to a crime novel, but this a unique combination of lyrical writing about the natural world and a perceptive story about human nature. The setting is the Canadian wilderness and the two central characters are intelligent and thoughtful young men, one one of whom has a heartbreaking trust in the basic goodness of his fellow human beings. The story gets of to a slow, almost impersonal, start, but do stick with it - if you are at all keen on the wilderness world or interested in the frailties of human nature and how we each cope in our different ways, you'll love it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A slow burn

I found it took me quite some time to get into the narration of this book. It does have lengthy descriptions of surroundings and events and I found myself drifting off quite a lot and having to rewind.

However, I found myself thinking of the story a lot when I wasn’t listening and at the end I found myself caught up in the emotion and hence the 4 star overall rating, rather than the 3 I was originally planning.

Somehow the book crept under my skin when I wasn’t looking...

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

More Than A Bit Disappointed :(

I was really looking forward to this story, as The Dog Stars (not on Audible for some reason?) is one of my favourite books.
The story started off with a lot of promise and although I'm not a huge fan of John Chancer's narrational style, I grew accustomed to the rhythm of it.
The two main protagonists were likeable and believable and the survival information, well researched and informative, it started off with an undercurrent and I was interested to see where it would all lead.
But then it all seemed to become a bit rushed and just like the fire, which was a major part of this book, it turned into a rushed, damp squib. (Maybe Peter's dinner was ready and he'd run out of ideas?)
All in all there were far too many unanswered questions, which is a shame and a bit of a disappointment.

P.S.If anyone could tell me what happened to Maia after the trip ended, I'd be very grateful. Or was she just the token, helpless woman, to make the capable men seem ever so manly?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

“Between the woods and the water”.

A story of men against nature and men with nature, brought to life wonderfully by John Chancer. Two college students canoeing a remote river encounter violence, and the force and fury of a forest fire. Gripping.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Beautiful written, abrupt ending

I enjoyed this book. The writing is evocative and the narration is good. I see some reviewers complaining about too much detail which I didn't find was an issue. I am a kayaker and spend plenty of time outdoors so the detail was useful and I empathised with the main characters. I really enjoyed the descriptions of nature and the discussion of our place in it.

What I thought strange though was how abruptly it ended. I think there would've been more consequence to the events in the story but these weren't explored at all. It just sort of stopped.

The character development of the main characters was superb but nonexistent for the supporting characters. Similarly, the drivers of the main characters to go on the trip was well developed but nonexistent for the others. Which is strange because there weren't many characters and their motivations were instrumental to the storyline.

All in all an enjoyable book but could've been a little better in character development development and ending.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!